Healthcare organizations and professionals need to be vigilant about maintaining patient privacy and complying with regulations like HIPAA. Violations can occur in many forms—whether accidental or intentional—and can lead to hefty fines, legal consequences, and damage to reputation. This article explores what constitutes a HIPAA violation, highlights the most common types, and provides guidance on how to avoid these costly mistakes.
—
What Constitutes a HIPAA Violation?
A HIPAA violation happens when an organization or individual breaches the standards established by the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996. While many violations involve improper access to or sharing of protected health information (PHI), violations can also include neglecting staff training or failing to monitor access logs. These breaches undermine the privacy and security of patient data and can be unintentional or deliberate.
HIPAA was enacted to modernize healthcare data management, especially in the digital age. The law sets out three core rules to safeguard patient information:
- The Privacy Rule
- The Security Rule
- The Breach Notification Rule
Enforced by the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) Office for Civil Rights (OCR), HIPAA’s regulations affect “covered entities” such as hospitals, insurance providers, healthcare clearinghouses, and certain providers who do not directly bill insurance. Vendors working with these organizations and handling PHI are also subject to HIPAA compliance.
Since its inception, HIPAA has been updated, notably through the 2009 HITECH Act, to strengthen data protection measures. Violations can range from minor oversights to serious breaches, each carrying potential penalties and legal actions.
—
The 12 Most Common HIPAA Violations
Understanding what actions can lead to violations is crucial for healthcare providers and their staff. Many breaches happen unintentionally, often due to lack of awareness or inadequate training. For example, losing a smartphone containing access to healthcare applications can be a violation, even if accidental. Additionally, breaches can occur when third parties convert physical x-rays into digital formats without proper agreements ensuring HIPAA compliance.
Since 2003, OCR has investigated nearly 300,000 potential violations of HIPAA’s privacy rule. Despite this high number, many healthcare workers remain unaware of what behaviors constitute violations. For instance, even a simple breach like sharing PHI without authorization can result in fines up to $50,000, and in some cases, criminal charges including jail time.
Categories of Common HIPAA Breaches
Violations can happen either deliberately or accidentally. Below are the 12 main categories:
- Lack of HIPAA Training: Failing to provide or document regular training sessions for staff often leads to violations.
- Inadequate Risk Analysis: Not conducting comprehensive risk assessments to identify vulnerabilities can result in security gaps.
- mishandling of Medical Records: Leaving paper records visible or unattended, or neglecting to lock screens, increases the risk of unauthorized access.
- Sharing Unencrypted PHI: Transmitting patient data over unsecured channels, such as unencrypted email, violates security standards.
- Neglecting Cybersecurity Preparedness: Not implementing measures to prevent, detect, and respond to cyber threats exposes PHI.
- Unauthorized Record Sharing: Disclosing records without proper authorization, especially outside treatment or billing purposes, is a violation.
- Device Theft or Loss: Lost or stolen devices containing PHI must be protected via encryption and access controls to prevent breaches.
- Inappropriate In-Person Discussions: Casual conversations about patients in public areas can accidentally expose sensitive information.
- Incorrect Patient Data: Human errors, like sharing wrong information or misfiling records, compromise privacy.
- Improper Disposal of PHI: Not shredding physical records or securely deleting digital files violates disposal protocols.
- Social Media Sharing: Posting images or details related to patients or healthcare facilities on social platforms can breach confidentiality.
- Missing Business Associate Agreements: Failing to have proper contracts with vendors who access PHI can result in violations.
More Complex Violations
Some issues are less straightforward. For example, losing a device containing PHI might breach HIPAA if it exposes patient data. Conversely, law enforcement agencies may not always be liable unless they operate their own healthcare services. The military, for instance, can disclose PHI for mission-related purposes under specific conditions, which complicates the violation landscape.
—
How Are HIPAA Violations Discovered?
In 2022, over 40 million health records were compromised, largely due to breaches reported by responsible employees. Covered entities often detect violations through internal audits or self-reporting mechanisms. OCR also conducts random audits and investigates complaints, which can prompt enforcement actions.
When a violation is identified or suspected, OCR evaluates whether an investigation is warranted. Organizations are required to cooperate fully; failure to do so can lead to further penalties. Importantly, HIPAA prohibits retaliation against individuals who report violations, and victims can seek guidance from OCR if they face repercussions.
Once an investigation concludes, OCR may require corrective actions, impose fines, or seek settlement agreements. These resolutions often involve compliance programs and periodic reporting to ensure violations are addressed.
—
Strategies to Prevent HIPAA Violations and Avoid Penalties
Preventing violations involves proactive systems, comprehensive staff training, and strict adherence to policies. Organizations should perform regular risk assessments, keep detailed records of training sessions, and establish clear procedures for handling PHI.
Tips for Covered Entities
- Conduct frequent and thorough risk analyses to identify security gaps.
- Maintain up-to-date policies and ensure all staff are trained accordingly.
- Establish clear contracts with business associates, specifying HIPAA compliance obligations.
- Know where PHI is stored, who has access, and how it is protected.
Tips for Healthcare Workers and Contractors
- Implement protocols to verify authorization before sharing PHI.
- Restrict discussions of patient information to private settings.
- Train staff and contractors on secure handling of data, including not sharing login credentials or leaving physical files unattended.
- Limit social media activity related to patients or organizational operations.
- Appoint a designated privacy officer to oversee compliance, handle inquiries, and coordinate training.
—
How StrongDM Supports HIPAA Compliance
Modern cybersecurity tools are vital in protecting digital PHI. The healthcare sector faces increasing cyber threats, making robust access management essential. StrongDM’s infrastructure access platform helps organizations mitigate risks by controlling and monitoring access to sensitive systems.
Features such as just-in-time (JIT) access ensure employees only access records when necessary, reducing misuse. Built-in session logging, alerts, and monitoring facilitate audits and breach investigations. Granular controls allow quick onboarding and offboarding of vendors and staff, maintaining strict access boundaries.
Implementing these security measures aligns with HIPAA standards requiring organizations to detect, respond to, and correct security violations. Effective access management not only reduces breach risk but also demonstrates accountability during audits.
—
Managing Access and Ensuring Patient Data Security
Long-term compliance demands continuous oversight of permissions, systems, and policies. Automating least-privilege access, centralizing logs, and restricting PHI to authorized personnel are critical steps. These practices simplify compliance efforts and help organizations stay ahead of evolving threats.
Interesting:
See how systems like this platform can support your compliance journey. Protecting patient data is a shared responsibility, and leveraging the right tools is essential for long-term success.
—
Frequently Asked Questions About HIPAA Violations
What is considered a HIPAA violation?
A violation occurs when an entity or individual fails to comply with HIPAA rules, such as unauthorized access, sharing, or failure to implement security measures.
What counts as a HIPAA breach?
Any unauthorized access or disclosure of PHI that compromises its security or privacy—whether accidental (like losing unencrypted devices) or intentional—constitutes a breach.
Where should violations be reported?
Violations should be reported to HHS by filing a complaint—most easily done through their online portal. Reports should be filed within 180 days of discovery.
Can HIPAA violations be reported anonymously?
While OCR requires contact details for investigations, you can mail a complaint form without identifying information or request confidentiality to protect your identity.
Are HIPAA violations criminal?
Yes, especially for willful violations. Penalties include fines ranging from $50,000 to $250,000 and jail terms up to ten years.
Can violations lead to termination?
Yes, violations can result in termination, particularly if intentional misconduct is involved. However, accidental breaches may not warrant severe penalties if promptly addressed.
Who can violate HIPAA?
Anyone with access to PHI—covered entities, employees, business associates, contractors, or volunteers—can violate HIPAA if they mishandle sensitive information.
Can individuals sue for HIPAA violations?
Generally, individuals cannot sue solely for HIPAA violations, but they can take legal action if they suffer harm from a breach, often through OCR or state attorneys general.
When should violations be self-reported?
Breaches involving unsecured PHI must be reported within 60 days; larger breaches require immediate notification. Reporting is essential to maintain compliance and avoid penalties.
—
Next Steps
Efficient access management and ongoing compliance are crucial for healthcare organizations. Tools like StrongDM streamline permissions, logging, and security, making it easier to adhere to HIPAA standards.
- Learn how StrongDM works
- Book a personalized demo
- Start your free trial today
Ensuring the privacy and security of patient information isn’t a one-time effort—it’s an ongoing commitment that benefits everyone involved.